I would expect there is a threshold for severity to a “crash” being reported. Falling down on a scooter is probably not going to be much worse than falling when walking, but falling on a bicycle is a little higher height and theres a frame between your legs. You can abandon a scooter mid-fall but not a bike. So even at a similar speed a bicycle is probably more likely to injure you more than a scooter this getting reported.

Thats just based in my crashing on scooters(20yrs ago) and unicycles vs bicycles. 

My question is does a crash per 1000miles on bicycle seem right? I guess its denser urban riding, and likely less experienced riders?

Ryan

On Dec 12, 2018, at 11:51 AM, Chip Wamsley via Bikeboard <bikeboard@bikemorgantown.com> wrote:

Interesting numbers.  Based on seven months usage, a single scooter would log 45miles/month and a single bike would log 10 miles/month.  It would be interesting to see numbers before scooter introduction. I don't see where the 30 times crash rate for bicycles could possibly come from.

---- Original Message ----
From: "Drew Gatlin via Bikeboard" <bikeboard@bikemorgantown.com>
Sent: 12/11/2018 7:59:46 PM
To: "Frank Gmeindl" <fgmeindl@gmail.com>
Cc: "Bicycle Board" <bikeboard@bikemorgantown.com>
Subject: Re: [Bikeboard] Austin dockless report

Wow, these are amazing numbers Frank! Thanks for sharing.

On Tue, Dec 11, 2018 at 7:29 PM Frank Gmeindl via Bikeboard <bikeboard@bikemorgantown.com> wrote:
Here’s an October 11, 2018 report from Austin, TX on their Dockless Mobility Program, http://www.austintexas.gov/edims/document.cfm?id=307564 
Some interesting statistics from April - October:
 
Number of devices in service
Scooters: 3,750
Bicycles: 1,200
 
Miles ridden
Scooters: 1,190,900 
Bicycles: 85,000
 
Number of crashes
Scooters: 37
Bicycles: 81
 
Computation: bicycles had 30 times higher crash rate than scooters.
 
None of the scooter crashes was fatal; 1 was life threatening; 16 had “significant signs and symptoms” and 14 were non-life threatening.
 
During the same time, Austin had 
Pedestrians: 14 fatalities; 112 injuries
Motorcyclists: 5 fatalities; 128 injuries
Motor vehicles; 10 fatalities, 2,336 injuries
 
At least in Austin, scooters look like a pretty safe way to get around.
 
Frank
_______________________________________________
Bikeboard mailing list
Bikeboard@bikemorgantown.com
http://wvcompletestreets.org/mailman/listinfo/bikeboard

 
--
J.D. Gatlin
Graduate Research Assistant
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering
B58 Engineering Sciences Building
West Virginia University
Chair, Morgantown Municipal Bicycle Board
Morgantown, WV 26505
_______________________________________________
Bikeboard mailing list
Bikeboard@bikemorgantown.com
http://wvcompletestreets.org/mailman/listinfo/bikeboard