Deborah
cc: Margaret Manousoff Please also mail to ; margaret(a)alaskaconservationsolutions.com<mailto:margaret@alaskaconservationsolutions.com>
Thanks you for the time and stimulating conversation last evening. I look forward to meeting with you when you are here in West Virginia. It is certainly a small world when we can connect with mutual friends like Judge Holland. I was always very proud to have been a close friend in Ann Arbor in our undergraduate days, and ever since, and …
[View More]then to read as he dealt with the EXXON Valdez oil spill case.
We had a spill here in West Virginia of toxic coal sludge that was reported to be 22 times the volume of the Valdez spill. It is quite a story of how the power of coal interests have successfully diverted any real consequences to the company, and in fact led to the termination of a very senior and dedicated environmental engineer on the MSHA staff because he told the truth about the mismanagement that led to the spill.
I look forward to sharing my other experiences in trips to Alaska...both in winter and summer...Hope, Kenai Peninsula, the crab dinners on the tip of the Spit in Homer...WOW...lots of memories for me.
In particular, I appreciate your suggestion that we could combine forces to bring the real impacts of global warming in Alaska to the realities and opportunities for West Virginia. I have giving my tailored version of the Gore Presentation about 20 times since last April's training in Nashville.
I try to tailor to the audience and to add my own 40 years of experience solving air pollution problems as an engineer in my native Canada, including 30 years in Southern California. And in the last 20 years I have been involved in addressing environmental policy and regulations in California as a consultant to industry and the regulators, addressing how clean technology solutions can in fact be good economics.
We are constantly being reminded daily that coal brings 50% of all electricity in the US, 95% in West Virginia, and that to suggest any alternative form of energy is speaking against the flag, motherhood, apple pie, jobs and all mankind...well, at least West Virginia's families. The Oxymoron "Clean Coal Technology" is being pounded into the citizens everywhere, while the truth of how dirty coal really is, is off limits for public discussion. And any speaker who speaks out about the dirty truth about coal is pillared as an enemy of the good working folks of the State.
So your planned tour is quite timely and appropriate. I would have as an objective to give you as much exposure as time will allow, and achieve a reality check for the few open minds of West Virginia, and some of the skeptics, to see why we cannot continue to use coal without achieving zero emissions.
Now as to the tour itself. There is not much time to plan this. And I am concentrating on Charleston, the State Capitol, as I do not have the same number and level of contacts in the other cities But we do have many of us who have received Margaret's e-mail able to work on a schedule.
I have a few questions:
1.. Are all details in place, and/or are there local folks working on this already?
2.. Do you have specific sites , halls, venues in mind or already arranged?
3.. How many presentations would be appropriate in this time period.
4.. Would you entertain TV and radio talk show interviews?
5.. As a member of the West Virginia Public Energy Authority, I could call for a special meeting just to receive your presentation. But as we, who are labeled global warming "alarmists", do not have a majority, that request may be denied.
6.. I see that you are a member of Rotary. Have you spoken to Rotary before? I am not a member, however, one of our very successful, but now retired corporate CEO's is in Rotary, so I could explore with him and see of the Friday that you are here would work. They may already have a speaker for that date.
7.. The memo from Margaret says that the tour is sponsored. Does that include any provision for fees or rent at any venues?
You are scheduled from the 10th to the 15th. That is over a weekend. What if any other plans do you have in those available days? My wife and I would certainly be interested in spending some quiet time to get to know you better. In fact, if you would like, you would be welcome ion our home while you are here in Charleston.
By the way, I have tried to e-mail Margaret, and I cannot get anything I write to go once I press the send button. One "computer guru" here suggested that it was because her e-mail address is too long.
I think that I can speak for all of us that we look forward to meeting you and doing what we can to make your tour here very successful.
Allan
Allan Tweddle
Quidvis recte factum quamvis humile praeclarum
Sir Henry Royce, 1924
[View Less]
____________________________________
From: website(a)stopthetowers.org
Sent: 3/11/2008 3:49:58 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time
Subj: Stop the Towers Update
March 9, 2008
Dear Friends and Neighbors,
Here is latest update on the Stop the Towers efforts and related issues.
You can always find the latest at the website and on the ECCO Hotline at
724-267-3040. Please stay involved and work to keep all your friends and neighbors
informed.
Buses Are Filling Up
The PUC Evidentiary …
[View More]Hearings in Pittsburgh are just two weeks away and the
buses are filling up! Beginning at 10:00 am on March 24th at the State
Office Building, the Public Utility Commission will begin hearings on the
proposed AP TrAIL. To assist the residents in Washington and Greene Counties, Stop
the Towers is organizing buses to take you up and back for the hearings.
For less than the cost of gas and parking, not to mention you won’t have to
worry about fighting the traffic, you can ride a bus with other Stop the Towers
supporters and be dropped off in front of the State Office Building. Please
contact Rebecca Foley (_rfoley1(a)windstream.net_
(mailto:rfoley1@windstream.net) ) as soon as possible to reserve your seat. Departure and return times
will be available from Rebecca.
TrAIL Co Sends Insulting Letter to ALJ’s
We believe it is important to have YOU attend the Evidentiary Hearings.
Apparently, TrAIL Co does not! Earlier this week, TrAIL Co sent a letter to
the Administrative Law Judges asking them to issue an order about proper
decorum in the courtroom. They caution the ALJ’s by asking for “observers in the
hearing room is (be) closely monitored for everyone's safety, and to permit
sufficient room for all the parties, counsel, witnesses and staff before
making space available for observers.” TrAIL Co is worried that we won’t
properly behave and would disrupt the proceedings. They point to the Public
Input Hearings and said that the supporters of TrAIL were “concerned about their
personal safety in returning to their vehicles”. First of all, isn’t that
ironic that the same company that has been sending land agents onto our
properties, harassing and intimidating people in their own homes, is now worried
about that same kind of behavior. Secondly, never has Stop the Towers
encouraged nor supported such behavior and we certainly are not now! We simply
believe that it is important to continue to put faces to the rural Americans
whose lives will be destroyed or at the very least severely disrupted should this
unnecessary, greed-driven proposal be approved!! So what are you going to
do? Contact Rebecca and reserve your seat now!!!
DOE does it Again!
Once again, the Department of Energy has ignored everyone, except the
utility companies that will profit greatly, by denying all requests for Re-Hearings
on the NIETC designations. Even with a number of environmental groups
filing lawsuit against the designations, the DOE continues to support a flawed
energy policy that will encourage long-distant transmission lines coming from
the highly polluting, coal-fired generation plants rather than cleaner, safer
alternatives. Better alternatives which include demand-side management
programs, conservation, upgrading existing infrastructure and the most reasonable
solution, building the generation plants near the demand. Utility
companies benefit greatly from section 1221 of the Energy Policy Act of 2005 as they
will be granted profits of up to 14% or more, passing ALL costs on to the
rate payers and all the while taking property and destroying the lives of rural
Americans. This is exactly what is happening here in southwestern
Pennsylvania with the proposed AP TrAIL! Fortunately, most environmental groups and
at least some of our Congressman see the flaws in this policy. We must be
thankful for people like Senator Casey and the others that recently requested
Senate hearings on section 1221. (You can see the letter on the Stop the
Towers website)Please continue to encourage Senator Casey and others to push for
the complete repeal of Section 1221 of the Energy Policy Act of 2005.
Specifically here in Pennsylvania, please contact Senator Specter (contact info
below) and encourage him to support a complete repeal of the above Act.
Senator Specter did sign Senator Casey’s letter asking for the hearings and he is
listening. But we must contact him and tell him our concerns because you can
be sure the utility industry lobbyists are talking with him every chance they
get. If he is not hearing from us, how is he to know what we are going
experiencing? Please email the Senator now. We need him on our side!
Senator Arlen Specter - United States Senator
Pittsburgh Office: Washington Office:
Regl. Entrprs. Twr. 711 Hart Building
425 6th Ave- Suite 1450 Washington, D.C. 20510
Pittsburgh, PA 15219 Phone: (202) 224-4254
Phone: (412) 644-3400
Fax: (412) 644-4871
Website: specter.senate.gov
Pittsburgh Office Staff Members
_Marybeth_McGowan(a)specter.senate.gov_
(mailto:Marybeth_McGowan@specter.senate.gov)
_stan_caldwell(a)specter.senate.gov_ (mailto:stan_caldwell@specter.senate.gov)
_adam_pope(a)specter.senate.gov_ (mailto:adam_pope@specter.senate.gov)
Stop the Towers!
For more information, go to _http://www.stopthetowers.org/_
(http://www.stopthetowers.org/) . If you feel you have received this email in error or no
longer wish to receive messages from Stop the Towers, a grassroots organization
dedicated to stopping the AP TrAIL, please reply to this email with REMOVE in
the subject line.
**************It's Tax Time! Get tips, forms, and advice on AOL Money &
Finance. (http://money.aol.com/tax?NCID=aolprf00030000000001)
[View Less]
I think it may be important to send more letters to the Senators on this committee (see below). It should also be important to find out if the Manchin Administration will offer testimony in opposition to NIETC.
JBK
>>> "Vivian Stockman" <vivian(a)ohvec.org> 3/10/2008 10:32 AM >>>
Senate to weigh DOE's power to overrule states
Law allows agency to dictate placement of power lines
http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/08069/863024-58.stm
Sunday, March 09, 2008
By Janice …
[View More]Crompton, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Opponents of a high-voltage power line project in Washington and Greene
counties have received encouraging news.
Last week, the U.S. Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee said it
would hold hearings to review how the U.S. Department of Energy is
implementing its controversial transmission corridor program.
The program allows the federal government to overrule state decisions about
placement of electric transmission lines. It allows property to be taken for
the lines using eminent domain, and has faced harsh criticism in recent
months.
Also new on the power line front, the state Public Utility Commission will
begin evidentiary hearings March 24 on the application of Greensburg-based
Allegheny Power to build the Pennsylvania portion of a proposed 240-mile,
500-kilovolt transmission line. The line would extend from Washington and
Greene counties in Pennsylvania to existing substations in West Virginia and
end in northern Virginia.
Allegheny's 210-mile portion of the line would cost $820 million to build,
with the total project estimated at more than $1 billion. The smaller
portion of the line would be constructed and paid for by Dominion Virginia
Power, which serves customers in Virginia.
Allegheny Power, calling the project the Trans-Allegheny Interstate Line
Project, or TrAIL, has already provided the PUC with testimony from 19
witnesses, while a local opposition group, the Energy Conservation Council
of Pennsylvania, has responded with three experts.
The company is facing challenges from more than just local groups, though.
Company testimony regarding the need for the power line so far has been
rebutted by two witnesses for the Pennsylvania Office of Consumer Advocate,
and from a supervisor from the PUC Office of Trial Staff, who called the
application "premature at best."
PUC Supervisor Gary Yocca questioned Allegheny Power's application after
analysis, testifying that the company had not yet done enough to merit
approval of the application.
Mr. Yocca said that while the company says the new power line is needed to
address anticipated local system failures and brownouts within the next
several years, he questioned whether there could be less costly and
intrusive methods.
He said the company failed to follow through on an assessment of the
environmental impact of the project and apparently no federal or state
agency examined the project. Mr. Yocca said there are questions about the
effects on farmland, forest land, plants and wildlife, and the significance
for historic and archaeological sites.
Other consequences loom
And, while he took note of local residents' objections to the scenic dilemma
presented by high-voltage transmission towers, Mr. Yocca warned of far more
serious consequences.
In his testimony, Mr. Yocca reminded PUC board members of the longwall coal
mining operations peppering Washington and Greene counties and of the
susceptible limestone ground structure.
He said the 125-foot to 150-foot transmission towers could be affected by
future mining operations or mine subsidence.
"If subsidence occurs under a [high voltage transmission line] tower, the
results could be catastrophic," he said.
Allegheny Energy spokesman David Neurohr said the company will address
rebuttal testimony from the PUC and other sources during the evidentiary
hearings.
"That will be the process," he said. "That is what they are for."
Will Burns, a lawyer with the Energy Conservation Council of Pennsylvania,
said his group is gearing up for the fight against the power company and
said he appreciates the work by Pennsylvania's state and national
legislative delegations.
He said the decision by the U.S. Senate Energy and Natural Resources
Committee to hold hearings "was indicative of how important Pennsylvania
legislators think this is."
A team of 38 Democratic state legislators, led by state House Majority
Leader Bill DeWeese, recently urged the Senate committee to investigate the
implementation of a provision in the Energy Act of 2005 that gives the
federal government jurisdiction over what has traditionally been state
land-use decisions.
Mr. DeWeese's letter to the committee came on the heels of one sent by U.S.
Sen. Bob Casey earlier last month.
Energy law at issue
Pennsylvania, along with a number of states, has objected to the Department
of Energy designating a large swath of the Northeast and parts of the
Southwest as a national interest electric transmission corridor -- or NIETC.
The Mid-Atlantic designation in the Northeast, which encompasses eight
states, the District of Columbia, and 50 of Pennsylvania's 67 counties,
means the federal government will have the right to overrule state decisions
involving the location of electric transmission lines and to take private
property through eminent domain for such projects.
If a state denies a construction permit to a power company, makes no
decision within a year, or places too many restrictions on the company, it
would have the right to seek a permit from the federal government if the
project is within a NIETC.
Already, Southern California Edison has asked federal regulators to approve
the siting of a 500-kilovolt electric transmission line through Arizona
after that state denied approval last year, saying it didn't want to be an
"extension cord for California."
Late last month, a vice president for Dominion Virginia Power testified that
the company would not rule out seeking federal intervention if state
approval is denied.
Mr. Casey has become the national voice against the large regional
corridors, which critics say defy the intent of the law -- to address
electric reliability and congestion after the 2003 blackout in the northeast
U.S.
Senators, governors and others have proposed that the corridors be of
reasonable size and include critically congested areas in need of
transmission and new generation. Local groups have expressed concern that
Western Pennsylvania's relatively cheap coal-fired electricity will be
shipped to the power-starved East Coast.
Senate to air concerns
Mr. Casey and other legislators have tried obstructing and amending the law
to no avail. Mr. Casey even threatened to delay the renomination of Joseph
Kelliher, Federal Energy Regulatory Committee chairman, to block
implementation of the NIETC.
The most serious concerns raised by officials include the failure by the DOE
to consult with states before the final NIETC designation and to assess
transmission needs and alternatives.
Another major concern was the lack of alterations to the draft NIETC
proposals last year. After more than 2,000 comments from the public, along
with state and local officials, the DOE published the final designation with
only token changes.
Last month, Mr. Casey sent a letter signed by 14 other senators to the
Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee, urging Chairman Jeff
Bingaman, D-New Mexico, ranking member Pete Domenici, R-New Mexico, to delve
further into how the transmission corridor program is being administered.
Last week, Leon Lowery, a member of the professional staff for the
committee, said there would be a hearing on the NIETC issues.
"There will be a number of hearings on electricity issues," he said. "Among
those things are the corridor issues."
Mr. Lowery said there has been no schedule set yet for the hearings, but
that the transmission corridors would likely not receive a separate hearing.
Janice Crompton can be reached at jcrompton(a)post-gazette.com or
724-223-0156.
First published on March 9, 2008 at 12:00 am
[View Less]
I will be traveling up to the Blue-Green Conf. in Pittsburgh tomorrow, so if
there is some other folks that could sit in on this call that would be
helpful. The section on Mercury would be esp. useful to us I believe.
thanks, paul
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Alice McKeown <Alice.McKeown(a)sierraclub.org>
Date: Tue, Mar 11, 2008 at 10:59 AM
Subject: REMINDER: National Coal Campaign Activist Call Wednesday, March 12
To: COAL-CAMPAIGN-ALERTS(a)lists.sierraclub.org
*NOTE:…
[View More] Please make sure to check out our Clubhouse Coal Headquarters
http://clubhouse.sierraclub.org/conservation/energy/coal/Default.aspx *
Our next national coal campaign activist call will be Wednesday, March 12th
at 8:00 p.m. eastern/ 5:00 p.m. pacific. Please join us for an update on
the campaign, a discussion on how the mercury court ruling may affect your
local plant, and an open forum for your questions.
Dial: 866-501-6174
Code: 224.0743#
Agenda
1. Welcome and campaign updates including recent news and victories (15
minutes)
2. Mercury: What the recent ruling means for activism, legal strategy, and
stopping new plants (15 minutes)
3. Open forum
Many thanks,
Alice
________________________________
Alice McKeown
Sierra Club
National Coal Campaign
tel: 202.675.6271
fax: 202.547.6009
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
To unsubscribe from the COAL-CAMPAIGN-ALERTS list, send any message to:
COAL-CAMPAIGN-ALERTS-signoff-request(a)LISTS.SIERRACLUB.ORG
Check out our Listserv Lists support site for more information:
http://www.sierraclub.org/lists/faq.asp
To view the Sierra Club List Terms & Conditions, see:
http://www.sierraclub.org/lists/terms.asp
--
Paul Wilson
Sierra Club
504 Jefferson Ave
Charles Town, WV 25414-1130
Phone: 304-725-4360
Cell: 304-279-6975
[View Less]
I picked up a new magazine (started Jan 2008) in Office Depot yesterday
called livebetter: http://www.centerforabetterlife.com/eng/magazine/
Here is how they describe their "sustainability" purpose:
http://www.centerforabetterlife.com/eng/about/
They have some interesting partners, and they are located in Newburg,
WV. Perhaps we should get on their list.
Does anyone know anything about them?
-Jonathan
-----Original Message-----
From: nietcwebmaster(a)anl.gov [mailto:nietcwebmaster@anl.gov]
Sent: Thursday, March 06, 2008 7:24 PM
To: Grubb, Karen
Subject: DOE Affirms National Interest Electric Transmission Corridor
Designations
************************************************************
National Interest Electric Transmission Corridors
************************************************************
DOE Affirms National Interest Electric Transmission Corridor
Designations
The U.S. …
[View More]Department of Energy (DOE) today denied requests
for rehearing of the Mid-Atlantic and the Southwest Area
National Interest Electric Transmission Corridors (National
Corridors) designated by DOE in October 2007 as areas of
significant electricity congestion and constraint. The
designation of national corridors was made in accordance
with the Energy Policy Act of 2005 (EPAct). In affirming the
National Corridor designations today, DOE dismissed as being
without merit challenges raised by the applicants for
rehearing, citing extensive data analysis conducted in its
2006 National Interest Electric Transmission study, ample
opportunity for public review and comment, and several other
key reasons.
The order and a related press release are available on the
"Order Denying Rehearing" page on the National Interest
Electric Transmission Corridors and Congestion Study Web
site at http://nietc.anl.gov/index.cfm
For More Information
********************
For more information about the National Interest Electric
Transmission Corridors and Congestion Study, visit
the National Interest Electric Transmission Corridors and
Congestion Study Web site at
(http://nietc.anl.gov/index.cfm), or contact us at:
nietcwebmaster(a)anl.gov
Forward This Message
********************
Please forward this message to any party you feel may be
interested in the National Interest Electric Transmission
Corridors and Congestion Study.
_________________CONTACTS/SUBSCRIPTIONS_____________________
FEEDBACK
--------
To submit feedback, contact the webmaster at
nietcwebmaster(a)anl.gov
PRIVACY POLICY
--------------
Our online privacy policy is at:
http://www.energy.gov/privacy.htm
SUBSCRIBE/UNSUBSCRIBE
---------------------
To subscribe or unsubscribe to the National Interest
Electric Transmission Corridors and Congestion Study e-mail
service, visit: http://nietc.anl.gov/email/index.cfm
If the above URL is not enabled as a link, please copy
it into your browser window to access our E-Mail
Services Page.
************************************************************
You are currently subscribed as:
kgrubb(a)fairmontstate.edu
************************************************************
[View Less]
The WGC plant proponents are mounting a petition campaign to convince
Senator Byrd to help them raise another $25 million, despite the fact that
they are way over budget, out of money and have defaulted on their loans,
which were guaranteed by the WV Development Office. The $25 million is so
they can borrow $300 million with municipal bonds through Citigroup and get
a grant from the US DOE for over $100 million. This use of taxpayers funds
for a bad idea must stop.
Letters are better than …
[View More]petitions. Please write a letter to Senator Byrd
(and you can send copies to Rahall and Manchin).
AND SEND A COPY TO ME SO WE WILL KNOW HOW OUR LETTER CAMPAIGN IS GOING.
AND FORWARD THIS TO ANYONE YOU CAN THINK OF.
Attached is the text from our fact sheet. If you can't open it, or want
more details, just let me know.
Byrd's address in Charleston (works better than DC; email and fax work too):
Senator Robert C. Byrd
300 Virginia St, #2630
Charleston, WV 25301
fax: 304-343-7144
email: from his website - http://byrd.senate.gov/
Rahall's address:
Representative Nick Rahall
301 Prince St.
Beckley, WV 25801
fax: 202-225-9061
email: nrahall(a)mail.house.gov
Manchin's address:
Governor Joe Manchin
1900 Kanawha Boulevard E
Charleston, WV 25305
Email: Governor(a)WVGov.org
Beth Little
HC 64 Box 281
Hillsboro, WV 24946
304-653-4277
No virus found in this outgoing message.
Checked by AVG Free Edition.
Version: 7.5.516 / Virus Database: 269.21.5/1314 - Release Date: 3/5/2008
6:38 PM
[View Less]
Report is attached. If you have trouble accessing it, let me know and I'll
send it in the message.
It occurred to me to mount a counter petition, but on second thought, I
think we should just have a letter writing campaign. They are much more
effective than petitions, and it's about time we let Byrd know what we think
about this boondoggle. As my roomate said when I told her the WGC guys want
Byrd to bail them out, she said, "I don't want any more of my tax dollars
spent on a coal fired …
[View More]power plant. I want health care, out of Iraq, my
roads fixed, education cleaned up."
So read at least the first part of this report and be thinking about what
you want to say to Senator Byrd. I'll send another message with those
talking points about the cogen plant and Byrd's address.
Also, I'm working on setting up a meeting next week to plan a response and
to distribute green bags.
Beth Little
HC 64 Box 281
Hillsboro, WV 24946
304-653-4277
No virus found in this outgoing message.
Checked by AVG Free Edition.
Version: 7.5.516 / Virus Database: 269.21.4/1313 - Release Date: 3/5/2008
9:50 AM
[View Less]